Brazilian Amazon: Deforestation, Dams, and Biofuels

January 28, 2008 at 7:48 pm Leave a comment

The Amazon Gets Less and Less Green
Friday, Jan. 25, 2008 By ANDREW DOWNIE/SAO PAULO

TIMES Magazine


Despite the alarms about global warming, the news concerning Brazil’s
crucial Amazon jungle is not good. Once again, satellites are showing
deforestation is on the rise. And once again the government has announced a
package of measures aimed at halting it. If you think you’ve heard this
story before, you’re not wrong. It’s depressingly familiar. “This is only a
surprise if you believe in Father Christmas,” said Roberto Smeraldi,
director of Friends of the Earth’s Brazil office.

The new statistics show that deforestation for the last five months of 2007
was 3,235 sq. kilometers (1,250 sq. miles or about the size of Rhode
Island), a rise from the previous year’s figure and alarming because
deforestation normally drops in the final rainy months of the year. In a
world panicked by its own carbon footprint, the forests of the Amazon are
the planet’s largest absorber of carbon dioxide.

Even more disturbing was an alert from another government agency warning the
true figure is closer to 7,000 sq. km. (2,700 sq. miles) “It is a completely
new and very worrying development,” Joao Paulo Capobianco,
executive-secretary at the Environment Ministry, admitted at a press
conference to announce the figures on Thursday. So worrying that President
Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva brought together several ministers to discuss
measures designed at halting the destruction.

Lula, elected with the support of green groups who later accused him of
kowtowing to Brazil’s powerful agribusiness lobby, called for a complete ban
on deforestation in the 36 worst-hit municipalities and said he would next
month send 800 federal police officers to ensure the moratorium is
respected. He also told landowners they would have to register their
properties and prove they comply with existing environmental legislation,
something very few currently do. Those not in compliance will be ineligible
for government credit or prohibited from selling their property. Measures
will also be introduced to stop non-compliant businesses from selling their

The measures are thorough and hard-hitting and many environmentalists
approve. However, in a remote region like the Amazon, where laws are more
suggestions than commandments, perpetual question marks surround
enforcement. The Lula administration has to truly want to bring landowners
into line, which is a big if, especially in a year of municipal elections,
said Paulo Adario, coordinator of Amazon campaigns of Greenpeace.

What is even more frightening is that the government may not even be able to
implement the laws, even if it wanted to. “These measures are very difficult
to implement,” Adario said. “But the problem is that while the government
knows where the deforestation is taking place it doesn’t know who is doing
it. They don’t know who owns what out there. Lots of people don’t have legal
papers, some of the land has been taken in land grabs and it is hard pinning
down the culprits.”

Environmental groups also believe the government’s commitment is
questionable because it needs the income from Brazil’s booming agriculture
sector. Brazil is the world’s biggest beef and soy exporter and it leads the
global race to turn sugar cane into fuel. When commodities like soy, beef
and grains are sought after on world markets, farmers have more incentive to
hack away and create fields. Environment Minister Marina Silva said the
recent rise in deforestation is due in large part to increased commodity
prices. Deforestation fell along with food prices in 2005 and 2006 and now
both are on the rise. Silva, however, meets counter-arguments from within
the government. The minister of Agriculture has rejected that theory and
argued that the amount of land given over to soy has remained constant for
four years.

Until the government operates from the same premises, real and concerted
change will remain elusive, said Carlos Alberto Scaramuzza, thematic
conservation director at the World Wildlife Fund-Brasil. “The government
needs to recognize that agribusiness, especially cattle ranching, is part of
the problem,” Scaramuzza said. “If we keep hearing the agriculture minister
saying that agri-business has nothing to do with the problem then we are
always going to be chasing our tail.”

Another worrying aspect comes in the westerly shift of deforestation.
Thursday’s figures show a large increase in forest degradation in Rondonia,
a remote state bordering Bolivia. Rondonia had avoided much of the
destruction but the new figures show that deforestation there is almost
equal to that in Para, a state five times the size.

Smeraldi put the rise down to a controversial government decision to license
two hydro-electric dams on the Madeira river, the longest tributary of the
Amazon. The dams could provide as much as 8% of Brazil’s energy needs but
they have been compared to China’s Three Gorges project because of the
potential ecological damage. Lula dismissed claims by his own environmental
agency that the dams could cause serious harm to the environment and ordered
a shake up that resulted in the ousting of officials who opposed the
project. The tender process went ahead last year, prompting a land grab
nearby, Smeraldi said. “This is the result of the speculation boom over land
that started in July 2007 when the Madeira dams were given the go ahead
without even studying the impact on deforestation and land issues,” he said.

Whatever the cause, Smeraldi and his colleagues in the environmental lobby
are gearing up for more bad news when the annual figures are released later
this year. Most of them swear they are optimistic by nature. But they know
how this story goes. They’ve seen it before. And it rarely has a happy


Entry filed under: Amazon News.

Bolivia challenges excessive investor protections New US Strategy: are you with or against Uribe?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Trackback this post  |  Subscribe to the comments via RSS Feed


Recent Posts

%d bloggers like this: